Can Car Insurance Drop You?

Doug Stockman • April 7, 2025

My Car Insurance Company Ghosted Me!

Insurance dropping me
TL;DR: Car Insurance Breakups (Cancellations) Happen:
Reasons for Cancellation: Poor driving record, dishonesty, non-payment, moving, or high risk.
Don't Panic: You have options even if dropped.
Find Out Why: Understand the reason for cancellation.
Shop Around: Use an independent agent to find new coverage.
Improve Your Situation: Clean up your driving or dispute unfair cancellation.

Car Insurance Breakups (Cancellations) Happen:

You've Been Dumped! (By Your Car Insurance? Seriously?)
Ah, the sweet, sweet security of car insurance. That warm, fuzzy feeling of knowing someone's got your back when you accidentally introduce your bumper to a mailbox. But what happens when they decide to break up with you? Can your car insurance company just...ghost you? Let's dive into this awkward scenario that happens in Spartanburg.

The "It's Not You, It's Me" Speech (Insurance Edition)

Yes, folks, car insurance companies can drop you. It's like a bad breakup, only instead of returning your mix CDs, they're canceling your policy. And just like any good breakup, they usually have their reasons (even if they sound like they were written by a robot).

Common Reasons You Might Get the Boot:

The "Lead Foot of Doom" Award: A string of speeding tickets, accidents, or reckless driving citations? You've basically written a love letter to higher premiums, and now they’re returning to sender. Upstate South Carolina has seen an uptick in citations. Watch the 3 Second Rule Video
The "Honesty? What's That?" Clause: Misrepresenting yourself or your driving record is like wearing a fake mustache to a police lineup. They will find out, and it won't be pretty.
The "Payment? Oh, Right" Oopsie: Failing to pay your premiums is like forgetting your anniversary. It's a big no-no, and it will hurt the relationship.
The "Moving to Mars" Clause: Companies have specific geographic areas, like states, they cover. If you move outside those boundaries, it's like a long-distance relationship that just won't work. If you live in South Carolina, have a car registered here, you have a South Carolina policy. If you move to North Carolina, you will need a policy for NC. The SC policy will have to be cancelled. And don't forget to turn the tag in and cancel the policy for the same date the tag was turned in.
The "Risk Factor: Off the Charts" Scenario: Sometimes, even if you’re a saint behind the wheel, if your overall risk profile is deemed too high, they might cut you loose.


What to Do When You Get the "Dear John" Letter:

Don't Panic (Too Much): It's not the end of the world. There are other fish in the insurance sea.
Ask Why: Get the lowdown on the reason for the cancellation. It's your right to know. Possibly there is a mistake, like being charged for a claim or ticket that is not yours. I have seen that happen with common names or 1 time a twin brother's claim was on his twin brother's record. We helped them correct the record and lowered the rates.
Shop Around (With an Independent Agent!): This is where we come in! Select Source can help you find a new policy that fits your needs and budget. We can shop many companies and find the best fit. We will optimize your coverage and costs.
Clean Up Your Act: If it was your driving record, start driving like your grandma is watching. Or a great tip from Select Source is drive like there is a baby sleeping in the back seat, unbuckled.
Dispute (If Necessary): If you believe the cancellation was unfair, you have the right to dispute it.
The Moral of the Story: Communication is Key

There are some companies that say they will never drop you. While this may be true, they don't say anything about how high the rates can go.

Like any relationship, communication is vital. Be honest, pay your bills, and drive safely. And if you’re ever feeling unsure, talk to your friendly neighborhood independent insurance agent (that’s us! Select Source Insurance). We’re here to help you navigate the sometimes-rocky road of car insurance.

In Conclusion: Don't Let Insurance Dump You!

Getting dropped by your car insurance is a bummer, but it doesn't have to be a tragedy. With a little knowledge and a good agent on your side, you'll be back on the road to insurance bliss in no time. And remember, driving safely is like sending your insurance company flowers – it always helps.







A close up of a cell phone screen with social media icons
By doug August 8, 2023
Protect Your Electronic Data
A man is installing solar panels on the roof of a house.
By doug April 6, 2023
Should I install Solar Panels
A silhouette of a person climbing a rock wall at sunset.
By doug February 17, 2023
The post Life Insurance FAQs appeared first on Select Source Insurance Group .